This is a draft of the A1 sized poster I will be presenting at LCDNets in a few weeks and I’d like some feedback, I’ll be printing tomorrow at 9am
Version 2 (Latest Version)
Version 1 (Original Version)
The following is my slide desk from a talk on PAWS, titled “Providing Security for Wireless Community Networks” at Workshop on Participatory Networks and Privacy: New Research Issues
I’m very pleased to announce that I’ll be presenting PAWS at this years ACM MobiCom Workshop on Lowest Cost Denominator Networking for Universal Access (LCDNet 2013)
We have been hard at work over the last few months, designing and securing the PAWS network. This is the outline of talk that I gave a few weeks back. The full powerpoint is available on Slideshare
Hi Everyone, My name’s Heidi and today I’m going to walk you through some of ideas behind Project PAWS, the Public Access Wifi Service. It should take about 15 mins to run you through our aims, the obstacles and we are trying to address them.
Internet Access – A Human Right ?
In July 2012, the United Nations unanimously backed a notion stating that “All people should be allowed to connect to and express themselves freely on the Internet”. Our aim is to address this and extent internet access to all, particular regarding access to essential public services.
Lowest Cost Denominator Networking
Mostly internet access today is done using “best effect” access, given the infrastructure available and the current state of the network, provide the best access possible, which of course comes at a cost. This creates only 2 possible levels of access: those who have internet access and those who don’t.
We aim to extend this, introducing a new level of basic access called less-than-best effort access, its has lower user requirements, thus reducing costs, helping to make internet access more widely available. According to the Internet World Stats survey of October 2012, more than 10% of the UK population don’t have internet access in their homes. This is what we hope to address.
Trial Deployment: Aspley Nottingham
Before tackling the issue nationally, we want to tackle it in one small area of the UK. For this, we have chosen Ashley in Nottingham. We chose this because according to the Nottingham Citizens survey, around 1/3 of citizens don’t have internet access. This is 3 times the national average, so if we can tackle the problem here, then hopefully we can tackle the problem anywhere.
The aim is to provide internet access to 50 citizens of Aspley who don’t currently have access. Our approach, is to enable citizens of Aspley with internet access to share their broadband with the wider Aspley community. For this we will be aiming to find 50 broadband sharers who are willing to help get 50 other Aspley citizens online. Once we have found our 50 sharers and our 50 new internet citizens, we hope to run a system to provide them with access for 3 months. We will then analyse the results, with the view to running similar project elsewhere (we have begin work with the University of Aberdeen towards a rural PAWS trial)
So far, this has already raised a range of interesting research questions such as:
The question that I am personally most interested in and will talk about today is: How can we build a system which allows individuals to share their broadband in a secure but easy to use manner that ensures that the shares internet experience is not notably affected ?
Broadband Sharing is nothing new …
Broadband sharing is nothing new, there are quite a few examples of similar projects, they are commonly known as “Wireless Community Networks”. Wireless Community Networks are were communities of individuals group together to form a co-op where individuals opt to share their broadband over WiFi and in turn they can use the WiFI of the other members of the community.
FON is the worlds most popular Wireless Community Network, with over 8 million members of the community. This demonstrates that individuals are willing to share their broadband, provided its sufficiently incentivised. FON demonstrates that its possible to build a system which allows individuals to share their broadband in a secure but easy to use manner that ensures that the shares internet experience is not notably affected. Job done
Well not quite… FON allows individuals with internet access to extend their access. PAWS aims to get individuals without internet access online, but these individuals (who make up 1/3 of the people in Aspley) cannot be part of a community like FON. FON does offer some limited access to individuals who don’t have a broadband connection but at a high cost (£6 for 90 mins at the BT FON Spot). PAWS aims to build on the ideas behind Wireless Community Networks like FON, but with the aim of providing internet access to essential public services to all.
The PAWS Model
PAWS aims to work with local partners such as local councils, community groups and charities to make access online available to all. Now for technical stuff. To meets our aims, we need to build a system with following properties:
Ease of Use
Firstly let’s consider the setup and install process for PAWS sharers. Most of the home routers that households in the UK use are provided by their ISPs. Often these are simply plugged in to the internet and left on the default settings. It wouldn’t be feasible for us to replace households home routers nor is it scalable for us to re-configure everyone’s home router. We could try to share WiFi in software, using a program such as Connectify to turn a sharers PC or laptop into a WiFi hotspot. This would require the sharer to leave their computer on, require the supported WiFi card and require us to support a range of PC platforms.
Therefore we will introduce new hardware, that will connect to the sharer network and enable broadband sharing in a secure and fair manner. Connecting using an ethernet cable, provides the best bandwidth and most reliable connection between the new hardware for sharing with PAWS and the sharer home network. For the hardware, we have chosen to use a router, called NETGEAR N600, WNDR3800 for its compatibility with software that we would like to run.
Routers, like this one, run special software called firmware. This is similar to how computer run an operating system like Windows 7 or MacOS. The firmware that will be running on the PAWS router is called OpenWRT.
This PAWS router will advertise the name “PAWS”, citizens can then use the internet by connecting to the WiFI network called “PAWS” in some areas of Aspley in Nottingham.
In order for us to make a PAWS sharers spare bandwidth available to the PAWS citizens, we need to measure the bandwidth available and use this information to decide how much bandwidth to make available to PAWS citizens. To measure the bandwidth, we run regular tests from the PAWS router. You can run a test right now to see how much bandwidth you get using a website such as www.speedtest.net orwww.broadbandspeedchecker.co.uk. For PAWS, we will be measuring the bandwidth using a tools called “BISMark”, made by a team at Georgia Institute of Technology.
In the 3 month Aspley deployment we will spend the first month, measuring the bandwidth available and the next two month making this spare bandwidth available to the citizens of Aspley. We will ensure that PAWS citizens only use this spare bandwidth by throttling the bandwidth at the PAWS router in the sharers homes.
We need to have a record of who has connected to the PAWS network and what they have used the network for. Therefore, we need all PAWS citizens to login when they connect to the PAWS network. In the same way that you need to login to WiFi at a cafe, train station or airport. For this we will use a software called RADIUS, which is also commonly used for managing the log in’s at public WiFi hotspots. RADIUS is used to for logging into many services online and therefore we could link PAWS to local services to allow PAWS citizen to be automatically registered and use the same password as they would for the local service. This will not be implemented in the trial deployment in Aspley
Accountability & Authorization
When you connect to the internet, you are known by number referred to as an “IP address”. You can find out the IP address that you are using to visit the internet now by visiting whatismyipaddress.com. IP addresses are allocated to households by their ISP and they can be used by the ISP to identify the source of any malicious activity online. PAWS citizens need to have a different IP address when they access the internet via a PAWS router than the sharers normal internet traffic. For this we use a Virtual Private Network (VPN), which sends all of the PAWS citizens internet traffic to another computer on the internet before sending it to the internet. This means that a all PAWS citizen will have a IP address that is different to that of the PAWS sharers. We can combine the VPN with RADIUS authentication so that all PAWS citizen log into the VPN with there own username and password.
Connecting to the PAWS network will therefore involve two steps: connecting to the WiFi network called “PAWS” and then login into the PAWS VPN.
A firewall, is a set of rules that govern what traffic can pass through a device, and we will run a firewall on the PAWS router to ensure that the only way to access the internet via the PAWS network is using the PAWS VPN
Confidentiality & Integrity
We need to ensure that PAWS sharers and citizens cannot see or change each others traffic. Wireless traffic is often poorly secured, this is why you shouldn’t check your bank account when using WiFi in a cafe. The use of VPN (as just described) means that we can easily encrypt PAWS citizens traffic from the citizen device like a laptop or mobile phone to a secure computer on the internet. This secure computer that all the PAWS internet traffic goes via is known as VPN server and hosted by local company ENMET.
Though Aspley is the first ever trial of PAWS, we hope that there will be many more to follow. We plan to enable PAWS citizens to login to PAWS within any of these deployments without needing to register
Our system isn’t perfect and there are some open issues to address. Firstly, not all devices are VPN compatible and on some devices which are, set up can be difficult. Fortunately in the Aspley trial we will have the PAWS team on hand to help PAWS citizens, though this isn’t scalable across the country. There are different type of VPN, offering different trade offs, unfortunately there is one type of VPN that is the all round best solution. In our own initial tests, we have found that some home routers, that have provided by UK ISPs, block VPN traffic by default. This is easy to fix by logging into the home router and changing a few setting but it does require the sharer to know there router’s username and password. The PAW’s routers currently cost about £110 each, which is fairly expensive. All PAWS traffic in the Aspley deployment is routed via a single VPN server, meaning that there is a single point of failure. In the Aspley deployment, we will welcome all PAWS sharers to becomes PAWS citizens but it would be nice if we could have greater incentives to share.
Ideas for Future Work
It would be nice to extend the incentives for members of the community to become PAWS citizens, potentially by introducing a two tier system where PAWS citizens who are also PAWS sharer are able to get more bandwidth on the PAWS network. Another potential improvement is to allow PAWS citizens who are also PAWS sharer, to use the PAWS router as a VPN server for there traffic. In the future, I would like explore the potential for replacing VPN with other security connectivity method such as WPA Enterprise. The PAWS citizens user experience could be streamlined by creating a mobile application to automatically connect to VPN when the user connects to a PAWS router, this application could then be extend to allow users to view a coverage map and add feedback about quality of access available at different points.
Thanks for Listening
As work on the Public Access WiFi Service (PAWS) continues, people regularly point us in the direction of other wide area WiFi networks. Potential we can learn a lot from these projects, from both the social and technical sides. Here I am going to try to focus on the technical details and the payment models:
For each project, I hope to us the following framework to access it:
Project Organisers and Partners:
Reason for funder to invest in project:
Time network was available ?
Cost to the user:
Service provided to users in terms of bandwidth, time browsering, websites available etc ?
Are the services provides allocated per user or per device ?
What form of user sign-up required ?
Can the user by-pass these restrictions ?
How is the WiFi network secured ?
Is the WiFi network open or encrypted ? If encrypted, how easily is the password available ?
Is the network vulnerable to rough access points ?
Is the network vulnerable to packet sniffing ?
Is the network/APs vulnerable to DoS attacks ?
Are the user informed of the importance of us a VPN or HTTPS
The following is a quick guide to setting up an virtual server on Amazon Cloud EC2:
1) Login to AWS Management Console using your Amazon account and navigate to EC2
2) In the top right hand corner, check that the location of the servers is the one that you would like to use, I will be using Ireland
3) In the “Getting Started” section of the EC2 dashboard, select Launch instance to create a new virtual server
4) I will be demonstrating the “Classic Wizard”
5) Select the Amazon Machine Image (AMI) that you would like to use, I will be using the Amazon Linux AMI 2012.09, 64bit edition
6) Enter the instance details, I am going to be creating 1 micro instance on EC2 so I’ve not changed any of the options on this page or the following Advanced Instance Options page or Storage Device Configuration page
7) Now you can create tags, using tags for your instances is really useful so I highly recommend it. I’ve set the key and value to “PAWS-router-management-server”
8) Creating a public/private key is vital for using SSH to access your virtual server. Give the private key a sensible name and download it
9) Creating a new security group is highly recommended, otherwise you can use make use the default group. I will be accessing the server using SSH so I’ve opened up port 22 to SHH
10) Review the opinions you have chosen and save
1) If you navigate to the “instances” page, you will now be able to see your newly created instance. Selecting your instance will give you access to more detailed information
2) To access your new instance, open the terminal and locate the private key you downloaded during set up
3) Change the permissions on the key using: $ chmod 400
4) Connect via SSH using: $ ssh -i
More details on the Amazon Linus AMI are available at http://aws.amazon.com/amazon-linux-ami/ . Its useful to note that there is no root password, you can’t SSH in as root or use su but if you use sudo, no password is required and that the package manager used is yum
Whilst at the All Hands Digital Economy Conference, I met Arjuna Sathiaseelan who told me about a new project called “PAWS: Public Access WiFi Service“. It sounds quite interesting and I might be joining the team in the next few months. The project poster is here : de2012
The main motivation behind the Public Access WiFi Service (PAWS) is to enable digital inclusion, which is important in the interest of social equality to ensure access to everyday services and benefits that are enjoyed by the majority, and ensure that all members of society are able to participate fully in the Digital Economy. Not only do the digitally excluded in societies currently not have access to these benefits, alternative provision of public services is a costly endeavour. While amongst the elderly the primary factor in digital exclusion is cultural (commonly that they do not perceive value in it), amongst younger demographics who want to be online, affordability is cited as the primary barrier, named by over 40% of digitally excluded 16-44 year olds. Most digital inclusion initiatives assume affordable broadband access, indeed the commercial imperative at the moment is to convert existing users to higher speeds, rather than deploy more widely; however we believe the notion of connectivity for all being governed by the simple market economics is a major impediment to achieving the benefits of a Digital Economy, and that basic Internet should be made available to all for societal benefit; a sentiment recently expressed by Berners-Lee. Although there is no single ‘magic bullet’ to remove socio-economic barriers, there are infrastructural solutions that could drastically reduce them. Our proposal is a first step in this direction: a feasibility study to establish technical requirements and identify the current practices and needs of the digitally excluded. Following successful demonstration, we hope that government policy can be nudged to support industry uptake leading to national deployment.
Our proposed programme of research seeks to inform and develop technology enabling free Internet connectivity for all, paving the way to new access models. We propose PAWS (Public Access WiFi Service), a new Internet access paradigm based on Lowest Cost Denominator Networking (LCD-Net) – a set of techniques making use of the available unused capacity in home broadband networks and allowing Less-than-Best-Effort access to these resources (lower quality service compared to the standard Internet service offered to paid users). Case study deployment of this technology will be underpinned by a programme of social research which will establish a socio-economic profile of the area, recruit potential participants and, most importantly, conduct a longitudinal multi-method assessment of participants’ current practices and subsequent experiences of this technology.
PAWS takes the approach of community-wide participation, where broadband customers can volunteer to share their high-speed broadband Internet connection for free with fellow citizens. Initiatives in the past have looked at sharing a user’s broadband Internet connection via their wireless connection (for e.g. BT FON). Although these methods are gaining worldwide acceptance, they are usually viewed as an extension of a user’s paid service – PAWS will extend this to support free access by users. As it is essential to ensure that the free user traffic does not impact perceived performance of the bandwidth donor, we will explore the impact of free services available through LBE access (also known as the Scavenger Class) to the network. These methods allow a person to use a shared link without competing for the resources of those who have shared their Internet connection. We will also explore the benefits offered by our proposed method to users and network operators. It is necessary for this work to be conducted ‘in the wild’ as it requires the deployment of technology to end-users, and subsequent assessment of its impact. The project will increase access opportunities, enabling digital inclusion and in turn supporting the UK Government’s ‘digital by default’ programme with its associated cost savings and service improvements”